With gold being a coveted investment asset for Indians, many prefer buying physical gold in the form of jewellery, coins, or bars. However, investing in sovereign gold bonds (SGBs) has become an attractive alternative to investing in physical gold. SGBs are government-issued securities denominated in grams of gold.
Let’s examine the benefits and drawbacks of both investment options for Indians:
Benefits of Investing in Physical Gold
- Tangible Asset
The biggest benefit of buying physical gold is that you own a tangible asset. Whether in the form of jewellery, coins, or bars, you can touch and feel your investment. This gives investors a sense of security that the asset actually exists and is their possession.
- Easy to Buy and Sell
Physical gold is easily available in India. You can buy gold coins and bars from jewellers, banks, post offices and even online. Selling physical gold is also easy, as local jewellers and online platforms readily purchase gold. The buying/selling process is simple.
- Asset Diversification
Including physical gold in your portfolio diversifies your assets across various investment classes – namely equities, fixed income, and commodities. This balances your portfolio and reduces overall risk.
Drawbacks of Physical Gold
- Storage Inconvenience
While storing small amounts of gold jewellery at home is easy, larger quantities of coins and bars need secure storage. Safety deposit lockers/bank lockers can provide this but come with annual fees. Storing at home could pose a theft risk.
- Purity Concerns
Ensuring the purity and authenticity of gold coins, bars and jewellery can be difficult for non-experts. You need to rely on the integrity of the seller. Testing and certification also add to the cost.
- Making Charges
Jewellery and coin-making involve significant making costs. This often results in the buying price of physical gold being higher than actual gold rates.
Sovereign Gold Bonds investment benefits
- No Storage Hassles
SGBs eliminate the storage troubles associated with owning physical gold. The bonds are held in demat (dematerialised) form and stored securely with depositories like NSDL/CDSL. You also save on annual locker fees and theft risks.
- Assured Purity
SGBs are issued by the Reserve Bank of India on behalf of the Government of India. This guarantees the purity and credibility of the gold asset underlying the security. You need not worry about purity or authenticity issues.
- Regular Income
SGBs pay an annual interest of 2.5% on the investment amount. This provides investors regular income during the 8-year bond tenure, unlike physical gold which generates no income.
Drawbacks of Sovereign Gold Bonds
- No Tangible Ownership
The biggest limitation of SGBs is that you cannot take physical delivery of gold. This denies the satisfaction and security associated with possessing tangible gold.
- Price Lag from Physical Gold
The SGB price tracks physical gold prices, but some lag can occur as SGB pricing is periodic. In contrast, physical gold prices react instantly to market changes.
- Interest Rate Risk
If market interest rates rise, SGB prices may fall – leading to losses when you sell the bond. So, interest rate movements can introduce some uncertainty in returns.
- Mandatory Lock-in & Exit Penalty
SGBs come with an initial lock-in of 5 years and exit before that entails a penalty of 50% of interest earned. So, full liquidity is constrained for several years.
SGB vs physical gold: Which is Better?
For most Indian investors, Sovereign Gold Bonds offer a better option than physical gold. Benefits like sovereign backing, tax efficiency, regular income, and storage ease make SGBs suitable for long-term holdings. However, those desiring complete liquidity or tangibility may prefer physical gold. Considering individual needs, both can find a place in an Indian investor’s portfolio for asset diversification and wealth preservation. Moderate allocation between SGBs and physical gold can allow investors to enjoy the advantages of both investment forms.